The work itself is believed to have been composed sometime between 385 bc and 370 bc. Eudaimonism and agency telos and philosophical knowledge in platos symposium yuji kurihara 15. Although pausanias is given a significant speaking part in plato s symposium, very little is known about him. If the translation is accurate, then many presentday beliefs about soul and platos concept of soul mates are at variance with plato or platos aristophanes. Pdf the contest of wisdom between socrates and agathon in.
Perfect for acing essays, tests, and quizzes, as well as for writing lesson plans. He is best known for his appearance in platos symposium, which describes the banquet given to celebrate his obtaining a prize for his first tragedy at the lenaia in 416. The symposium is considered a dialogue a form used by plato in more than thirty works but in fact, it is predominantly a series of essaylike speeches from differing points of view. The virtuous life in greek ethics which plato himself has made prominent, forcing us to recognize them as problematic. This will necessarily be selective since i am concerned here with what. Its legacy has been far reaching, inspiring religion and mysticism, to visions of art, the good, and the beautiful. Symposium quite clearly, it means love of something. Agathon s speech is applauded as brilliant, but socrates has a few pointed questions about agathon s characterization of love. Platos writings are typically in the form of dialogues in which socrates.
However, he claims there are two kinds of love, for which reason he describes them both before giving praise to the one he thinks is worthy. The first task will be to outline the central claims of each speaker. Symposium by plato the speech of agathon and socrates. Pdf on jan 1, 2004, steven robinson and others published the contest of wisdom between socrates and agathon in platos symposium. The symposium is one of the foundational documents of western culture and arguably the most profound analysis and celebration of love in the history of philosophy. Platos symposium tran lated by benjamin jo w ett wi t h an introduc t ion by fulton h. Dover the date of platos symposium, phronesis 1965 10.
Character list apollodorus narrator aristodemus told. The first edition of the novel was published in 385, and was written by plato. Ancient anecdotes tend to address only his relationship with agathon and give us no information about his personal accomplishments. After they have finished eating, eryximachus picks up on a suggestion of phaedrus, that each person. Platos symposium greek and latin texts with facing. Platos symposium is one of the most iconic works of literature in the western tradition. Agathon failed to see that love, by its very nature, is always a love of something love desires that which it loves. Sept 2014 10 mb this link contains a free pdf copy of platos symposium. Around 407 he removed himself from athens to the court of the macedonian king archelaus. The aim of each speaker at agathons symposium is to offer an encomium to eros which amounts to showing that it is a good thing and has good effects. Apollodorus, who repeats to his companion the dialogue which he had heard from aristodemus, and had already once narrated to glaucon. Take a firm grasp of this point, then, said socrates, remembering also, though you may keep it to yourself for the moment, what it is that love is love of. Agathon, socrates, alcibiades, a troop of revellers. This is a comparison of agathons role in aristophanes thesmophoriazusae and platos symposium.
Agathon concludes with a rhetorically complex eulogy praising every aspect of love, who is responsible for beauty, excellence, mildness, wisdom, goodness, excellence, and much else besides. By this i mean, after my reading symposium, i have come to see that the ideas about love that i was taught were platos, were more interpretations of what platos ideas about. The aim of this commentary is to make platos symposium as accessible as possible to intermediatelevel greek readers so that they may experience the joy, insight, and lasting influence that comes from reading some of the greatest works in classical antiquity in the original greek. Symposium socrates and agathon summary course hero. A philosophical text about the genesis, purpose and nature of love, and is the origin of the concept of platonic love. Love, he claims, is not the oldest of the godsas phaedrus had impliedbut the youngest and most beautiful, with the ability to change shape at will. Symposium is central in platos philosophy, since it talks about love and ideas commentary on plato symposium. The symposium philosophy learning and teaching organization. A reading of platos symposium james velasquez 172a177a. A tragedian who had just the night previously celebrated his first award as a writer, gave arguably the most amusing speech of the initial six. As you were so careful to point out to us, agathon, one, must elucidate the entialnature and characteristics of love before describing his cts.
Jan 27, 2018 this is a brief overview of platos symposium. What path will bring us into a closer apprehension of beauty while. First, by showing that the dialogue develops a critique of a specific form of education within the framework of paiderastia, a social convention which appears as a response to the quest for knowledge philosophia, and how this critique of paiderastia. The symposium tells the story of a drinking party in which the guests agree to put aside their desire for wine, women and music and deliver speeches in honor of eros, a word often translated as love but more aptly described as sexual desire or passionate love. Socrates and aristodemus will attend a banquet at agathon, with aristophanes, appolodore, pausanias and eryximachus. Concerning the things about which you ask to be informed i believe that i am not illprepared with an answer.
T h e n, sa id eryxima bus, th e weak heads like myself, aristod e mu s, ph aedru s, a nd othe rs who nev er can drink, are fortunate in findin g tha t the s tronge r on es are not in a drinking mood. Agathons speech is applauded as brilliant, but socrates has a few pointed questions about agathons characterization of love. Agathon, pausanias, and diotima in platos symposium. Agathon is giving a banquet in celebration of his victory in. In his speech agathon takes an approach similar to that of phaedrus, focusing on loves attributes as a divine being i.
The national endowment for the humanities provided support for entering this text. Learn exactly what happened in this chapter, scene, or section of the symposium and what it means. Firstly, i examine the platonic version, and the unique, idiosyncratic part plato gives agathon to play, as a host to all, and a hostage to socrates. Socrates arrives at the party late, as he was lost in thought on the neighboring porch. In his speech agathon takes an approach similar to that of phaedrus, focusing on love s attributes as a divine being i. To a banquet at agathons, he replied, whose invitation to his sacrifice of victory i refused yesterday, fearing a crowd, but promising that i would come today instead. Phaedrus speech was followed by several others which aristodemus remembered poorly, so apollodorus continued on to tell of pausanias speech. The question of agency in platos symposium carolina araujo 21 eudaimonist closure in the speeches of platos symposium david t. While based on historical settings and people, the symposium is to be approached as a work of fiction, as are the rest of platos dialogues. Ashbrook statesmanship thesis recipient of the 2012 charles e. Although pausanias is given a significant speaking part in platos symposium, very little is known about him. So dialogue plays a smaller role in the symposium than it does in platos other dialogues.
These papers were written primarily by students and provide critical analysis of symposium by plato. In using the symposium, or wineparty, as a setting for his dialogue. Jan 08, 2020 platos symposium is one of the most iconic works of literature in the western tradition. Symposium by plato the speech of pausanias summary and. Pdf on nov 1, 2008, freddie rokem and others published the philosopher and the two playwrights. Written 2,400 years ago, platos philosophical novella, symposium, includes one of the weirdest and most charming explanations of why people fall in love ever invented. Pausanias began by reminding the gathering that their purpose was to give speeches praising love. The dialectical interchange between agathon and socrates. A philosophical text about the genesis, purpose and nature of love, and is. Giulia sissa salon before the surprising evocation. Eros and lifevalues in platos symposium stephen halliwell 7 the ethics of eros. Agathon told the attendants to go and see who were the intruders.
Plato constantly challenges the tragedycomedy dichotomy in the symposium, and agathon s speech is a major element in this challenge. It is also the most lavishly literary of plato s dialoguesa virtuoso prose performance in which the author, like a playful maestro, shows off an entire repertoire of characters, ideas, contrasting viewpoints, and iridescent styles. This site is like a library, use search box in the widget to get ebook that you want. Together with pausanias, he later moved to the court of archelaus, king of macedon, who was recruiting playwrights. He argues that agathon has attempted to make love appear as attractive and perfect as possible without any regard for the truth. Free download or read online the symposium pdf epub book.
Telos and philosophical knowledge in platos symposium yuji kurihara 15 il ruolo e limportanza della dimensione esperienziale ed empirica nel simposio maurizio migliori 20 who loves. A little while afterwards they heard the voice of alcibiades resounding in the court. It is truth that you find it impossible to withstand. The book was published in multiple languages including english, consists of 1 pages and is available in paperback format. The symposium opens with apollodorus telling an unidentified friend the story of a banquet that it is said has been told many times before. Mattingly the date of platos symposium, phronesis 1958 3. The crazy and charming theory of love in platos symposium. I will try, taking the conclusions on which agathon and i reached agreement as my startingpoint, to give the best consecutive account i can of what she told me. Those who consider the first part of the parmenides in isolation tend to suppose that plato had heroically come to grips with the. Many people prefer to read offline or to print out text and read from the real printed page.
The impossibility of evil without ignorance and the progression toward good. Forms as perfect exemplars socrates in the middle dialogues symposium, phaedo, and republic, the exchange is usually interpreted as a negative assessment by plato of the adequacy of his earlier presentation. The story of the symposium or banquet held at agathon s house and attended by socrates. Symposium is central in platos philosophy, since it talks about love and ideas.
Apollodorus relates to an unnamed companion a story he learned from aristodemus about a symposium, or dinnerparty, given in honor of the tragedian agathon. The guests decide not to get drunk, but drinking a little and discuss about love. Platos symposium and the traditions of ancient fiction, richard hunter 14. Phaedrus pausanias eryximachus aristophanes agathon socrates alcibiades a troop of revellers scene the house of agathon. While the republic may be more famous, symposium is the most graphic, intense, and dramatic of the dialogues. Agathon was the son of tisamenus, and the lifelong companion of pausanias, with whom he appears in both the symposium and platos protagoras. Not only in the symposium, but in other of his writings, plato is skeptical about the value of tragedy. Apollodorus, glaucon, and the road to agathons platos symposium begins with the reader being introduced to apollodorus1, the narrator of the piece and a close follower of socrates.
Pdf the symposium book by plato free download 1 pages. The symposium is about love, eros more specifically. In the book, platos symposium, by plato, who was a philosopher in greece, he illustrates the dialectic discussion at a party at agathons to celebrate his triumph of his first tragedy. Plato the symposium download ebook pdf, epub, tuebl, mobi.
Socrates as a divine intermediary in the apology and symposium gerard naddaf 246 agathon 247 why agathons beauty matters francisco j. Anselm feuerbach, the symposium second version, 1873. Full text views reflects the number of pdf downloads, pdfs sent. Influence of the symposium on legal theory, jeffrey carnes part iv.
The love of wisdom is the highest form of lovephilosophy. Pdf the speech of agathon in platos symposium david n. Socrates draws on gorgias when questioning agathon, not as parody, but alluding to the standards of what is likely, eikos, established by him and his school of orators. A concise, accessible and studentfriendly introduction to a key text in ancient philosophy. However, this method of socrates and his speech are generally attributed to be platos own ideas and theories. According to greek mythology, humans were originally created with four arms, four legs and a head with two faces. The gathering takes place at the house of the tragedian agathon. Phaedrus, pausanias, eryximachus, aristophanes, agathon, socrates, alcibiades, a troop of revellers. Docs love desire the thing that he is love of, or not. My goal in this contribution is to shift the center of interest of platos magnificent dialogue the symposium on two points. Purchase a copy of this text not necessarily the same edition from. It is also the most lavishly literary of platos dialoguesa virtuoso prose performance in which the author, like a playful maestro, shows off an entire repertoire of characters, ideas, contrasting viewpoints, and iridescent styles. Click download or read online button to get plato the symposium book now. A symposium scene on a 5th century bce greek cup currently housed in the state antiquities collection in munich, germany.
1189 754 309 525 990 531 561 1156 1238 775 719 1324 1513 329 996 1080 708 816 557 1289 25 1469 123 1255 1097 1385 1218 881 972 799 1141 1385 882 584